Roger Ebert brandished his old media sword as he crept into the lair of the internet, defiantly shouting that games could never be art. He stood against a torrent of nearly 2000 comments on his personal blog, and an innumerable quantity of blog posts like this one referencing his mantra. He remains stalwart; a protector of all true art until the day he dies no matter how many flames he must endure or 20-somethings telling him he just has to play Shadow of the Colossus.
The question we, as gamers, must ask ourselves is thus: who cares?
Who cares what labels are placed on a medium? Who decides what is art? Certainly not a critic grounded in only one medium and certainly not a games-obsessed youngster either.
What does the label of art imply? Prestige? Government funding? Respect? Saying something is “Art” does nothing to the content. It’s simply a superfluous packaging on top of a product that already affects our emotions one way or another.
(more…)